Displaying items by tag: Inclusion

A neighbourhood safety group should make it easier for people to seek help and feel at home in their streets. That purpose is compromised when residents themselves become targets of suspicion because of their appearance or background. For Neighbourhood Watch, a commitment to community safety must include the people who might otherwise be treated as outsiders.

A Guardian investigation published on 12 September 2026 identified at least 28 anti-migrant vigilante groups formed in the UK over eighteen months. [1] This is a journalistic finding, not an official census or evidence of a comparable trend across Europe. The investigation does not establish a connection between those groups and recognised Neighbourhood Watch schemes. It raises a separate but relevant question: how can community safety organisations make the boundary between civic participation and self-appointed enforcement unmistakable?

For EUNWA, the issue concerns the credibility of civic participation. Residents should be able to recognise what a legitimate neighbourhood group does, whom it answers to and how to raise a concern about its conduct. The distinction is not between people who care about safety and people who do not; it lies in what groups actually do, whom they target and whether they respect others’ rights.

 

Drawing the Line: Vigilance without Vigilantism

Neighbourhood Watch can give residents useful ways to act on concerns: sharing reliable prevention advice, encouraging reports of specific incidents to the appropriate authorities and helping neighbours reach support. Membership does not confer police powers or authority over other residents. Indeed, the Neighbourhood Watch Network advises that crime should be reported to the police or another appropriate reporting service, not to Neighbourhood Watch as though it were an enforcement agency. [2] National organisations should state these limits plainly in volunteer guidance and public communications.

One existing reference point is the Neighbourhood Watch Network, the national umbrella charity supporting Neighbourhood Watch in England and Wales. Its published ethics and standards require fairness, impartiality and respect for privacy. Volunteers are expected to make decisions based on facts, accept responsibility for their conduct and challenge or report discriminatory behaviour within the movement. [3] These are relevant examples for European discussion, not rules that can automatically be attributed to Neighbourhood Watch organisations in other countries.

Applying these principles requires attention to ordinary decisions. Consider a hypothetical neighbourhood message describing an unfamiliar person as suspicious without identifying any concerning behaviour. A coordinator should ask what was actually observed and stop speculation about nationality or religion from becoming an allegation. Where someone reports a specific threat or offence, the priority should be accurate information and an appropriate official response. A group chat must not become a vehicle for identifying, shaming or mobilising against individuals.

Nor should every community walk or public discussion about safety be equated with vigilantism. The warning signs are more specific: attempts to stop or question people as if exercising official powers, intimidation, discriminatory targeting, or calls for residents to take enforcement into their own hands. A group’s stated intention to protect its neighbourhood cannot excuse such conduct.

 

Accountability, Inclusion and Trust

The same care should shape volunteer recruitment and oversight. Organisations could discuss practical scenarios with prospective coordinators, including how they would respond to a discriminatory comment or a request to confront someone. Written responsibilities, a named point of contact, a complaints route accessible to non-members and a process for responding to breaches would make expectations easier to enforce. The England and Wales Network, for example, publishes guidance on withholding recognition from coordinators who breach national guidelines and removing non-compliant groups from its database. [4]

Inclusion also needs to be visible in whose concerns receive attention. A resident experiencing racist harassment should be able to approach a neighbourhood group with the same expectation of being heard as someone concerned about burglary. Local organisations could work with migrant associations and victim support services to understand barriers to participation. Invitations alone may be insufficient if residents have reason to doubt that their experiences will be taken seriously.

The England and Wales Network’s Hate Crime Community Ambassador project offers one model for examination. The published project page describes a trial in the Royal Borough of Greenwich, combining awareness work and encouragement to report with role-specific training, an application and interview process, and regular review sessions. [5] A programme description does not establish impact, nor does it show that the model has been implemented throughout England and Wales. European partners considering comparable roles should examine local training, supervision and ways to assess participants’ experiences.

Police partnerships should make responsibilities equally clear. Community groups need an agreed route for concerns, guidance on responsible information sharing and a way to discuss recurring problems. They should be able to question an inadequate response and seek explanations through appropriate channels. Such scrutiny is compatible with cooperation; it does not justify assuming the authority to control other people’s movements or demand explanations of their presence.

Political independence matters as well. Members may hold different views on immigration or public policy, but those views should not determine who receives help or who is treated as a suspect. A neighbourhood organisation’s activities and communication channels should remain focused on community safety rather than party-political mobilisation. This does not prevent members, acting as private citizens, from participating in lawful public debate.

EUNWA could turn these principles into a practical comparative exercise: examine how national Neighbourhood Watch organisations define volunteers’ roles, train coordinators, handle complaints and respond to misuse of their names or channels. Residents who have felt excluded or unfairly scrutinised should be heard alongside volunteers and police partners. The central test is whether commitments to safety and inclusion are reflected in everyday practice, including for those who have the least confidence that a neighbourhood group will stand beside them.

Sources

[1] Patrick Greenfield and Michael Goodier, ‘Number of UK anti-migrant vigilante groups surges in last 18 months’, The Guardian, 12 September 2026 (updated 14 September).

[2] Neighbourhood Watch Network, ‘Reporting a crime’.

[3] Neighbourhood Watch Network, ‘Ethics and standards of behaviour’.

[4] Neighbourhood Watch Network, ‘Frequently asked questions’ (safeguards for legitimate groups).

[5] Neighbourhood Watch Network, ‘Become a Hate Crime Community Ambassador’.

 

In an era marked by growing distrust of institutions and a widespread sense of insecurity, Neighbourhood Watch schemes have become an increasingly common feature in many European cities. Born with the goal of increasing safety through active citizen participation, these groups often find themselves at a crucial crossroads. They can evolve into powerful tools of social cohesion or, conversely, unintentionally become catalysts for populist drifts, fuelling division and fear.

Understanding this dynamic is essential for anyone who cares about both security and the health of the democratic fabric.

A Fertile Ground for Populism

The correlation between populism and Neighbourhood Watch is no coincidence; the former can create the ideal conditions for the latter to emerge. Populism, especially in its right-wing form, thrives on a precise narrative: that of honest, hardworking "people" betrayed by corrupt, distant "elites" who are incapable of protecting them from threats like crime and decay. In this view, the state is portrayed as inefficient, weak, or even complicit.

This rhetoric undermines trust in traditional institutions, such as the police and the judiciary, which are often depicted as being too "soft" or lacking resources. It is in this void of trust that the populist call for direct action takes hold. Feeling abandoned, citizens are urged to "take back control" of their own security. A Neighbourhood Watch scheme can thus become the most concrete manifestation of this impulse: an act of self-organisation that bypasses institutions and asserts the sovereignty of the local community.

Furthermore, the populist tendency to identify a scapegoat—the immigrant, the minority, the "other"—provides these groups with a tangible enemy. The fear of an external threat acts as a unifying force, pushing residents to unite not just for something (security) but also against someone.

The Boomerang Effect

While populism fosters the birth of these groups, it is equally true that the groups themselves can become a powerful vehicle for populist ideas to take root. This "boomerang effect" manifests in several ways:

  • The very existence of the group and its actions (a report, a presumed thwarted burglary) become living proof of the state's failure. The neighbourhood chat group turns into a sounding board where anxiety is amplified and the narrative of institutional inefficiency finds continuous confirmation.
  • Within the group, a strong sense of belonging based on exclusion is strengthened. The "us" are the respectable residents defending the territory; the "them" is anyone perceived as an external threat. This shifts the focus from crime vigilance to social surveillance, where even non-illegal but simply "different" behaviours can become an object of suspicion. This mechanism generates an exclusive "bonding social capital" that strengthens internal ties but builds walls against outsiders.
  • Neighbourhood Watch groups can easily become a political incubator, a training ground for local leaders who, gaining visibility and consensus on security issues, find an ideal platform for a future political career, often aligned with populist parties.
  • The issue of security ceases to be a complex social problem and becomes a simple moral battle between "good" and "evil." This fuels the demand for simplistic and punitive solutions, a cornerstone of populist rhetoric.

Towards an Inclusive and Democratic Model

Is it inevitable then that a Neighbourhood Watch scheme will slide towards populism? Absolutely not. It is possible to design and manage these groups in a way that makes them a bulwark against polarisation and a driver of genuine cohesion. The key is a paradigm shift: moving from a fortress mentality to a town square mentality, from defence to inclusion. This requires the adoption of some fundamental principles.

  • Partner with institutions. The group should not be born as an antagonist to institutions but as their partner. Formal agreements with local, regional, or national authorities are crucial for defining roles and boundaries. The regular presence of a police liaison officer at meetings and adequate training on the legal limits of citizens' actions can transform distrust into collaboration and prevent vigilante behaviour.
  • Embrace inclusion. A healthy group must reflect the neighbourhood's actual composition. A proactive effort is needed to include residents of every nationality, culture, and social background. Multilingual communication, the involvement of migrant associations, and horizontal, rotating leadership are effective antidotes against the creation of an exclusive "us."
  • Focus on community. The group's energy should be channelled not just towards surveillance but especially towards improving the quality of life. "Situational" prevention—like advocating for better lighting or the redevelopment of a park—increases real and perceived safety without fuelling a climate of suspicion. Initiatives such as neighbourhood parties, collective clean-ups of green spaces, or the creation of urban gardens build the kind of "bridging social capital" that unites people rather than dividing them.
  • Communicate responsibly. Populism feeds on moral panic. To counter this, internal communication within the group must be rigorous. It is crucial to rely on official crime data provided by authorities rather than anecdotes and hearsay. A strict rule should be established against the spread of unverified news, and language should be adopted that talks about problematic "behaviours," not categories of "people."

A Choice to Make

Neighbourhood Watch is not inherently "good" or "bad." It is a tool, and like any tool, its impact depends on how it is used. If left at the mercy of fear and distrust, it can easily become a weapon in the hands of populist propaganda, eroding social cohesion and undermining the principles of the rule of law.

If, however, it is built on solid foundations of collaboration, inclusivity, and active community care, it can transform into an extraordinary exercise in active citizenship. A healthy Neighbourhood Watch doesn't build higher walls; it builds longer tables. It is not measured by the number of "enemies" it identifies, but by the number of neighbours it brings together. Ultimately, the choice between being a fortress and an open town square rests with the community itself.

 

Save
Cookies user prefences
We use cookies to ensure you to get the best experience on our website. If you decline the use of cookies, this website may not function as expected.
Accept all
Decline all
Functional
Tools used to give you more features when navigating on the website, this can include social sharing.
Unknown
Accept
Decline
Marketing
Set of techniques which have for object the commercial strategy and in particular the market study.
Quantcast
Accept
Decline